Cleveland school district
Roof repair at John F. Kennedy High School in Cleveland has been categorized as an 'urgent necessity' even though it has been on a project list for at least two years.
Roof repair at John F. Kennedy High School in Cleveland has been categorized as an 'urgent necessity' even though it has been on a project list for at least two years.
Roof repair at John F. Kennedy High School in Cleveland has been categorized as an 'urgent necessity' even though it has been on a project list for at least two years.
Roof repair at John F. Kennedy High School in Cleveland has been categorized as an 'urgent necessity' even though it has been on a project list for at least two years.
Roof repair at John F. Kennedy High School in Cleveland has been categorized as an 'urgent necessity' even though it has been on a project list for at least two years.

Watchdog panel says Cleveland district circumvents bid requirements on summer construction projects

Aug. 3, 2016
By categorizing work as "urgent necessities," school board has avoided competitive bidding on many jobs

The panel that serves as a construction watchdog for Cleveland schools says the district routinely skips basic steps in awarding millions of dollars in "summer work" projects.

The Cleveland Plain Dealer reports that that the Bond Accountability Commission concluded that the school system could save money if it followed its own established bid procedures.

"State law and Board of Education policy generally require competitive bidding or multiple price quotes before contracts are awarded,' the Commission says, "but in the Cleveland district’s repair/improvement program, exceptions are the rule, thanks in large part to the Board of Educaiton’s annual 'urgent necessity' resolutions."

The commission says that some of the bids in question could have been considered emergencies, but many of them were for "repairs and improvements that have been planned for months or even years, leaving plenty of time for bids or quotes."

Out of $11.5 million in work in 2013 and 2014, the district did not obtain bids or quotes on more than one third of the jobs that normally require them. It also skipped bids on a half-million dollars worth of technology purchases and repairs that probably required bids.

The most extreme example of a longstanding "urgent" problem is work on the roof of John F. Kennedy High School. The project appeared on the "urgent" list two years ago, then again last summer and is on the list yet again.

The panel recommends that the district use the "urgent necessity" exemption "only in emergencies and unforeseen cases requiring immediate attention."

Sponsored Recommendations

How to design flexible learning spaces that teachers love and use

Unlock the potential of flexible learning spaces with expert guidance from school districts and educational furniture providers. Discover how to seamlessly integrate adaptive ...

Blurring the Lines in Education Design: K–12 to Higher Ed to Corporate America

Discover the seamless integration of educational and corporate design principles, shaping tomorrow's leaders from kindergarten to boardroom. Explore innovative classroom layouts...

Room to Learn: Furniture Solutions for Education

Preparing students for the future. Utilizing our experience in the education market, we offer a dynamic selection of products that pair technology with furniture to help stimulate...

Transforming Education: A Case Study in Progressive Classroom Design

Discover how Workspace Interiors and the Baldwin School District reshaped learning environments in Long Island, New York, creating pedagogically responsive spaces that foster ...